Showing posts with label Shrewsbury Town. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Shrewsbury Town. Show all posts

Sunday, 15 April 2012

Ten Years Ago...

Ian Dunbavin watches on (picture from Luton Town)


Shrewsbury Town 0-2 Luton Town
20/04/02 Gay Meadow, attendance 7,858

Shrewsbury Town: Dunbavin, Thompson, Rioch (Moss 62), Tolley, Redmile, Heathcote, Lowe, Atkins (Murray 73), Rodgers, Guinan (Aiston 52), Woan. Subs not used: Wilding, Cartwright.

Luton Town: Emberson, Neilson, Perrett, Coyne, Taylor, Forbes (Boyce 87), Hughes, Spring, Valois (Johnson HT), Howard, Crowe (Kabba 66) Subs not used: Hillier, Ovendale.

Ten years ago, before relegation, Everton, the Conference, New Meadow, Joe Hart, play-off finals, Paul Simpson and the ultimate return of the messiah, Town went into the last game of the season looking very healthily level on points with Rushden & Diamonds in the final play-off spot.

Going into the final match


With a win needed to guarantee a ticket in the play-off lottery, and both Hartlepool and Scunthorpe breathing down Town’s neck, the opponents that bright day in 2002 were the already-promoted Luton Town, a team left with nothing to play for following Plymouth’s 4-1 title-winning romp against Darlington the previous Monday.

Of course, Town lost that day, and with both teams behind winning, ended up finishing 9th. But with much changing in the subsequent decade, it’s worth taking a trip down memory lane and seeing just how much things have changed...

Players

In 2002, it was considered the norm for Division Three clubs to sign creaking old Premier League rejects on relatively massive salaries, their commitment as questionable as their waistband and their lives lived on past glories. Sporadically capable of the odd dead-ball reminiscent of the good old days, but mainly a lumbering burden with their head stuck in 1993, Kevin Ratcliffe was a particular fan and whilst he seemed to get the blend somewhat correct this season, it would prove his undoing the following year. I’m looking at you, Ian Woan.

This practice has thankfully been stamped out at Town in recent years and especially by Graham Turner. These days, Town have had significant purchasing power thanks to a combination of Joe Hart money and being generally very well ran in recent years – I’ll generously gloss over rising ticket prices and an increasing sense of detachment from the average fan – and genuinely exciting young players have been a regular feature.

Several ex-Town players have made it to the Premier League recently, and nearly as impressive as the youth team products of Hart and Dave Edwards have been players such as Marc Tierney and Grant Holt, who have shown that the difference between the very top and the basement division has significantly contracted. Players in League Two are fitter, faster, and more skilful than they were ten years ago as even the lower league game becomes big business.

Of course, all squads at this level will always have the journeymen and for Steve Guinan and Andy Thompson ten years ago read Ian Sharps and Marvin Morgan today. The rules mentioned above still apply though (or is it Town simply improving?) as Sharps and Morgan have both had their moments in coming across as very good footballers who could easily play at a higher level. Morgan’s clothing company provides threads to JLS: a 2002 equivalent of this might be Greg Rioch supplying One True Voice, which seems a bit less likely. 

Rioch and Morgan: times change (pictures from Shrewsbury Town and Shropshire Star)



Another constant in League Two will always be a gamble on cost-effective youngsters, but whilst several of the 2002 XI came through Town’s system, the majority today are brought in from elsewhere as standards rise. Graham Turner’s team simply would not carry substandard young players for sentiment’s sake (as has finally been proven with Steve Leslie), instead preferring to bring in highly-rated kids on loan from larger clubs. As standards have rise along with Town’s budget, the reliance on home-grown talent has – for good or for bad – resided. This said, potential top players such as Jon Taylor and Tom Bradshaw will always find a way into the side: but Karl Murray they are not.

Manager

We all know what happened to Ratcliffe’s Shrewsbury the following season, with the high of Everton tempered by a shameful relegation. He jumped before he was pushed ahead of the last game against Scunthorpe, of which Mark Atkins took charge despite some brilliant rumours regarding Frank Skinner.

Jimmy Quinn, Gary Peters, and Paul Simpson all had their good times and bad, the latter two scraping Town into the League Two play-offs with two equally dramatic semi finals followed by two equally lifeless final defeats. Quinn remains the only manager since 1994 to win promotion with Town, setting the precursor with two shootout victories in the 2004 Conference play-offs after finishing about 634 points below losing semi-finalists Hereford.

The return of Graham Turner has brought a change in attitude and a genuine buzz around the club, and for the first time in my 13 years of watching Town I am genuinely convinced by promotion this season. Watching Town play good, winning football and with swelling attendances, the next decade looks far more promising than this or many of the ones before it.

The club

People say what they like about New Meadow – and I certainly have done regarding its soulless, sterile atmosphere and boring identikit design – but nobody can even begin to pretend that we would ever advance with Gay Meadow.

One of the most charming and romantic grounds in the Football League, two words which actually, of course, mean ‘decrepit’ and ‘ramshackle’, only the most plastic, heartless, clipart fan wouldn’t miss it dearly. We’ve all got our sepia-tinged Meadow memories, but the truth has gradually been absorbed: for Town to ever challenge the upper reaches of the Football League, the Greenhous Meadow is a necessity.

The Riverside - a glorious relic


Elsewhere: Roland is still Roland, Lenny is still Lenny, and you still see the same faces in the ticket offices and club shop, which is no longer a portakabin. The cheapest adult Early Bird season ticket for 2012/13 sets you back £270 compared to £208 ten years ago, a 30% rise, with juniors rising from £120 to £150.

Another change has been the hugely popular switch to the new badge, which manages to promote strong brand diversity and corporate awareness whilst remaining in touch with the fanbase and the roots of the club. Or something like that.

A note on the opposition

It’s fair to say Luton have had their own share of drama in the subsequent decade since promotion that season. Promoted as Champions to the Championship in 2005, this was quickly followed by three successive relegations which included 40 points deducted in the latter two seasons for various financial problems. One merciful bright spot was the 2008/09 Johnstone’s Paint Trophy, won on the backdrop of a gallant attempt to claw back their 30 point deduction that season.

Things have quietened in past couple of years for the Nick Owen-owned club (well, except for this, obviously) as they have struggled to break out of the Conference – and at the time of writing they once again look unlikely to win a place in the play-offs. Luton look like slipping into a rut that Town may only have avoided thanks to Scott Howie’s heroics.

What if...?

So... what if the score was reversed in this game and Town took a 2-0 victory into the play-offs? Cheltenham would have been the opponents, finishing five points ahead but having already lost 2-1 at Gay Meadow that season. Rushden & Diamonds would have waited at the Millennium Stadium having only finished ahead of Town on goal difference.

If they had been beaten, how would Town have coped in Division Two? Would funds have been made available to make Town a constant at that level? Would we still have the new ground, and would it be the same? How would Luke Rodgers and Sam Aiston handle the step up? Would Town have done a Luton and ended up in the Championship? Or would we have just come straight back down and delayed relegation to the Conference by one more season – an inevitability of the club’s state at that time?

More on Shrewsbury Town:





Sunday, 17 July 2011

From the Banks of the River Severn

...to the shores of Scandinavia, Australasia, Africa, and many others, but sadly not Sicily – yet. Gone are the days when players from Ireland were considered exotic, and with easyjet and the European Union making the football world ever smaller, even a quaint little lower league side like Shrewsbury Town can build up a decent XI of overseas alumni, nine of whom own representative honours of some description.

To keep things fair, I’ve only included players who were either born abroad – obviously – or who are English-born but have represented their adopted country at some level - meaning Andreas Arestidou misses out, but Ömer Rıza, the proud holder of a Turkey B cap, makes the cut.

GK: Benny Gall
I have to confess it’s a poor start for me, since Benny Gall was slightly before my first ever Town game, but word of mouth and the internet have both informed me of the Danish ‘keeper’s existence. Making 34 appearances between 1996 and 1998, Gall may not have set the world alight but probably had a more exciting career than Scott Cooksey and Mark Cartwright – winning a Danish U21 cap in 1990, he left Town to join Esbjerg fB in his homeland’s Superliga.

Esbjerg were relegated in 2000 but a year later Gall joined Danish giants FC Copenhagen, where, as a reserve ‘keeper, he won four titles and was part of several Champions League squads. Making just eight league appearances in six years, this Scandinavian Stuart Taylor now manages in the third tier.

RB: Jason van Blerk
Overpaid, past his best and unfit – a classic Kevin Ratcliffe signing. Before lumbering around Gay Meadow in the glorious relegation season, van Blerk actually made 33 appearances for Australia in the 1990s whilst featuring for West Brom, Millwall, and the Netherlands’ Go Ahead Eagles. 

Collector's item - Sagi Burton's signed St Kitts and Nevis shirt


CB: Sagi Burton
Sagi, or Osagyefo Lenin Ernesto to his mum, was born in Birmingham but made three appearances for Saint Kitts and Nevis in 2004 whilst playing for Peterborough. Alongside his ‘Boro teammates Calum Willock and Adam Newton, aggressive defender Burton played in a 2-0 friendly defeat to Northern Ireland, before featuring in both legs of a tie against Barbados in the second round of CONCACAF qualification for the 2006 World Cup. 

Saint Kitts won 5-2 on aggregate with Newton and Willock both scoring, before losing all six games in the group stage with a goal difference of minus 22. The trio were called up again for the Caribbean Cup qualifiers in 2006, but this time decided that Peterborough was more attractive than Barbados and stayed at home.

CB: Shane Cansdell-Sherriff
Versatile SCS has played a solid three seasons for Town so far and shows no sign of stopping. Shane also played for Australia’s under 23s at the Athens Olympics in 2004, featuring against an Argentina side including Carlos Tevez and Javier Mascherano in the group stage, before losing a quarter final against Iraq. In March this year his strong, consistent performances for Town led to a call up to the full squad for the first time.

LB: James Meredith
I admit this one is a bit forced, and mainly because Thomas Nielson was before my time, but Meredith was indeed born in Australia and did indeed play for Shrewsbury Town. Three times. Very poorly. He found his level during a loan spell at Telford, and now plays regularly for York City. According to his Wikipedia, he once dated a Page Three girl. Well done James.

Derek Asamoah (left) signs for the Pohang Steelers


RM: Derek Asamoah
Another with an interesting career, Ghanaian winger Asamoah worked the backwaters of England’s lower leagues before joining Town in 2006. A successful season climaxing in a Wembley play-off defeat was followed by a hugely acrimonious transfer to the French top tier side Nice, as Gary Peters referred to the striking striker as “a selfish player and a selfish person” – both parties handling the situation with an admirable lack of playground dignity.

Peters’ voodoo doll must have taken a serious pounding however as Asamoah spent two luckless and gameless years in France before making three appearances for the mighty Hamilton Academical. As one of Derek’s privileged 3000 Facebook friends, I have witnessed the pictures of successful subsequent moves to Lokomotiv Sofia and now to South Korea’s Pohang Steelers, where he plays in front of 17,000 obsessive Koreans in the K-League. Asamoah has made four appearances for Ghana since 2006.

Terry Dunfield celebrates his first international goal


CM: Terry Dunfield
Another to leave under a bit of a cloud, many Town fans cursed Thierry Dunfield for wanting to return to his home city to earn more money, play in a higher quality league and perhaps play for his country. What a bastard.

Canadian Thierry began his Town career with some truly diabolical performances after joining in January 2009, before becoming one of the team’s key players the following season, a metronomic midfielder who glued the side together. A first international cap followed, with Canada manager Stephen Hart famously and publicly telling him he needs to play at a higher level, which Thierry duly sought in 2010.

A move to Vancouver Whitecaps seemed like a winner all round then, and as the team struggle through their debut MLS season Thierry has been the star in a poor team. Five more international caps have followed as promised, including a goal against Ecuador, and a recent move to Toronto FC will put him at a stronger level.

CM: Gylfi Sigurðsson
He may well have only played five games on loan from Reading in 2008, but other than Joe Hart, Sigurðsson has reached greater heights than any other recent Town player. Despite his slight build at the time, he was a convincing playmaker whose quality over most of his teammates was painfully obvious.

After a handful of games for Town, Gylfi had another loan spell at Crewe before breaking into Reading’s first team in 2009. Twenty-one goals from midfield, including an injury-time equalising penalty at Anfield, won him Reading’s Player of the Season and much interest from Premier League clubs, but it was Hoffenheim in the Bundesliga who won his signature in 2010 in exchange for £6 million.

In his first season for the cash-rich Germans, ten goals and another Player of the Season award followed for the still-young midfielder, who has now earned five international caps for Iceland on his way to becoming one of their most important players. Away days at Bayern Munich must seem a far cry from a Tuesday night at Accrington Stanley.

LM: Benjamin van den Broek
It would be reasonable to say that Benji, a likable chap who was clearly a talented footballer, was never really given a fair crack of the whip at Town. A strangely inspired signing by Paul Simpson, rescued from the ashes of his previous club HFC Haarlem’s bankruptcy, the Dutch forward never got the run in the team that his talents deserved. Injuries and a lack of a real position didn’t help his case, and nor did the arrival of Graham Turner who just didn’t seem to fancy him.

After just eleven appearances in more than a year, Benji has since joined FC Den Bosch in the Eerste Divisie, the Dutch second tier, where Ruud van Nistelrooy began his career. I have a strange feeling that like so many discarded Town players, the decision to release van den Broek will come back to haunt us. 



CF: Kris Bright
Another interesting Paul Simpson signing, hopes were high for New Zealander Kris Bright as we watched the above video of his (solitary, against Thailand) international goal. Completely underwhelming, but difficult to judge definitively since he never seemed to come on before 85 minutes, Bright generally flattered to deceive but did have occasional moments of quality before joining Budapest Honvéd – once the home of Ferenc Puskás.

Unfortunately for New Zealand, that’s where the similarities to the legendary Hungarian end, with no caps being added since Bright’s fourth – which in fairness did come against Spain at the 2009 Confederations Cup. Once named by Football365 as the worst player at the 2010 World Cup, Bright didn’t actually make the final squad and was left as a reserve – tellingly, Rory Fallon was taken instead.

CF: Guy Madjo
“We’ve got Guy Madjo, better than Eto’o” the chant optimistically went, as rumours went around of Madjo once being picked ahead of Samuel Eto’o for Cameroon. This, unfortunately, was a slight exaggeration – our hero was simply picked as a non-playing replacement for one of the world’s best strikers as Eto’o suffered one of those convenient injuries which somehow always seem to crop up before international friendlies.

This wasn’t the end of Madjo’s Indomitable Lions career however – he was named in the provisional under 23 squad for the 2008 Beijing Olympics, which excused him from the first few weeks of Town’s season. Madjo featured in a friendly against Japan, but evidently didn’t impress as he missed out on the final squad and returned to Shropshire with his tail between his legs. After a promising start to his Town career, the striker faded, and left for rather unexpected spells in China and Albania before recently signing for Stevenage.

Heat's 2007 Torso of the Year, and star of Turkey A2 Team


Subs:
Thomas Nielson Danish left back of the mid 1990s.
John Keister Absymal midfielder for Town, made two appearances for Sierra Leone.
Ömer Rıza Once played for Turkey A2 – their B team. Awful for Town.
Rory Fallon Terrible loanee from 2001 now has 10 caps for New Zealand.
Glynn Hurst Has apparently earned five caps for South Africa under 23s.
Fola Onibuje Utterly dreadful Nigerian winger who played one League Cup game for Town.
(Is there a theme here?)

More articles on Shrewsbury Town:



Monday, 20 June 2011

Joe Hart and 21 Others (Part Two)


There were three other continental players lining up for United – Mads Timm, Markus Neumayr and the one and only Floribert N’Galula. Whilst no constituent of this exotic triumvirate made the grade at Old Trafford, all forged professional careers of some descripton: German midfielder Neumayr currently graces the Swiss Premier League with FC Thun and Mads Timm retired in 2009 after an injury struck few seasons in his Danish homeland, nevertheless being called up for Denmark (without playing) after impressive performances for Odense BK (coincidentally the home of another United reject, Eric Djemba-Djemba). Belgian midfielder N’Galula plays in the Finnish Premier League for Turun Palloseura, home of Football Manager hero Mika Ääritalo, after an ill-fated month-long spell for DC United in the MLS proved fruitless.



Our tour of the more obscure leagues in Europe continues with another trip to Denmark, where, as mentioned at the start, two of our own ply their footballing trade. Their travel itinerary shown above, left back Adam Eckersley and centre half Mark Howard are big successes for AGF Aarhus, with Mark being voted player of the season in 2011 as AGF were crowned champions of the Danish First Division. Whilst neither of the Salford lads made an impression at United, credit to them for gambling on success abroad when countless others, including several in this match, have instead been happy to settle for a lower level English club.

Those middling players of varying quality who, whilst not qualifying as a success on the Hart/Piqué scale, have forged accomplished and, to the rest of us at least, lucrative careers in the lower leagues include former England U21 and Cardiff City ‘keeper Tom Heaton and Ipswich winger Lee Martin, both of whom are established Championship players. Aged 25 and 24 respectively, both players still have much chance to play regularly in the Premier League – Heaton especially, accounting for the dearth of English goalkeepers at present. 



Moving down the leagues, Ritchie Jones is currently available on a free after a successful spell in midfield for Oldham, as is winger David Poole following Stockport’s relegation. Both however have played more than 100 games in the Football League, which is more that can be said of Colin Heath, a striker who spent six years as a non-playing professional at Old Trafford followed by mediocre performances for Chesterfield, Macclesfield, and finally Farsley Celtic before an early retirement. Still, this practically makes him Pelé when compared to sub ‘keeper Lee Crockett, currently in nets for Deeping Rangers (whose ground is shown above, next to Old Trafford for comparison), in the Hereward Teamwear United Counties League - five divisions below the Football League.

Around this period, United ran two reserve teams – the one featuring here in the Pontins Holiday League, and another in the FA Premier Reserve League North. The Pontins team was dropped not long after this season, and as a result many of these players sadly found their development stunted by a dramatic decrease of playing time.

Of the Town regulars, Ryan Lowe spent last season scoring 27 goals to fire Bury to League One, being trusted by Alan Knill and Richie Barker in a way he sadly never really experienced at Shrewsbury. However, this is fairly irrelevant here since Lowe didn’t actually feature in this reserve fixture – a late, post-teamsheet-printing change of heart brought in Ross Stephens, a left sided player who had some involvement in the first team before naturally moving to the Welsh Premier League where he is something of a club whore – at the time of writing, Prestatyn Town are his sixth club in the division.



Utility man Jake Sedgemore plays at Nantwich Town under the co-stewardship of two ex-Town teammates, Kevin Street and Darren Tinson (above), whilst Dave Ridler is player manager at Prescot Cables playing a division below. Jamie Tolley, who like reality television seems to have been around forever, is incredibly still just 28 and playing for Wrexham in the Conference, whilst Dave Walton, a true Town hero after his first successful spell in the mid 1990s, was forced to retire at the end of 2005 as a knee injury ruined his Indian summer. 



Former League Cup finalist Martin O’Connor, playing in the twilight of his career, had a final few games for Kidderminster in 2005 before assisting Chris Hutchings in the destruction of Walsall. In 2000 the balance of internationals in this match may have been swung to Town’s favour as the Cayman Islands sneakily tried to exploit their status as a British Overseas Territory by simply calling up British players such as O’Connor, who, along with others of emphatically non-Cayman heritage, played a friendly against DC United before FIFA stepped in and made possibly their only logical decision of the decade in disallowing it.

As it stands, the international count is critically level – along with Piqué and Hart each side provides a home-nations regular, both of whom seem stuck in that purgatory gap between the Premier League and the Championship. 



Paul McShane starred in the Championship for West Brom in 2006/07, winning his first Irish caps that season, before earning a move to the big time with Sunderland paying £1.5m for the defender as he became another disciple of Roy Keane’s beard. McShane didn’t set the world alight at the Stadium of Light though as the following summer he moved again to newly-promoted Hull City, initially on loan, and took part in Phil Brown’s famous sit-down teamtalk at Eastlands – a move which quite impressively ruined Hull’s entire season after what had been a good start at that point. Tellingly, McShane returned to Sunderland in January and Hull escaped relegation, before signing permanently that summer. After which Hull were promptly relegated. 



Out of all of United’s famous FA Youth Cup victories, their 2003 triumph over Middlesbrough was probably the most underwhelming. No member of that team remains at Old Trafford, with Kieran Richardson and Chris Eagles having the most success for the first team, which tells you all you need to know (although Phil Bardsley and Sylvan Ebanks-Blake have proved moderately successful elsewhere). McShane, Timm and Collett started that final, with Heaton, Howard, Calliste and Poole on the bench – and ex-Shrewsbury loanee Lee Lawrence at left-back. Sadly for many of the players in United’s side that day, it represented the only highlight of their entire football career – although on the losing side, Ross Turnbull, David Wheater, Andrew Taylor, Chris Brunt and James Morrison all started.

Perhaps the most pleasantly surprising success from a Shrewsbury perspective has been Dave Edwards. Whilst Joe Hart was always clearly talented, it wouldn’t be impolite to state that many Town fans considered Dave Edwards, especially alongside his partner in haircuts Jamie Tolley, a bit of a luxury. Still, after Mark Atkins handed him his debut against Scunthorpe in the last game before the Conference Season, he gradually improved, and his controversial dropping by Gary Peters before the playoff final is still debated to this day. 



A tribunal-set fee of £250,000 led to a move to the struggling Luton Town, where Edwards hung around just long enough to impress in a 1-1 FA Cup draw with Liverpool and earn himself a £675,000 transfer to Wolves, where he remains. Edwards played a key part in Wolves’ promotion to the Premier League in 2008/09, but has since struggled with injuries and has not featured regularly in the top flight. A highlight this season has been scoring the winner past his old friend Joe Hart in a 2-1 win over City.


You can find Part One here. The final part, including Ramon Calliste, Ben Collett and an actual match report, is here.